SiteLeadJobs data / November 3, 2026
The same contractors post pay where the law says to, and mostly nowhere else.
22 large contractors hiring field leaders in both kinds of state put pay on 90% of their postings in states that require it, and on 22% in states that don't. Same companies, same roles, same week.
The gap, in three numbers
90%
of postings show pay where a posting law applies
n = 496
22%
of postings show pay everywhere else
n = 1,266
39%
of postings show pay in VA, ME and CT, whose laws started this year
n = 33
The 22 are the contractors on SiteLeadJobs with at least three open salaried field-leadership jobs in a posting-law state and three in a state without one. Across the whole board, which adds smaller firms that hire in only one kind of state, the split is 90% and 19%.
It isn't a mix effect. Comparing each contractor's own postings, role by role, the gap is still 64 points, and 14 of the 22 show a gap of 40 points or more on their own.
By state
Share of the 22 contractors' postings that show pay, states with 25 or more postings. Navy = posting law in force; gold = none.
| State | Bar | Show pay | Postings |
|---|---|---|---|
| New York (posting law) | 100% | 31 | |
| Washington (posting law) | 95% | 39 | |
| California (posting law) | 94% | 145 | |
| Minnesota (posting law) | 90% | 87 | |
| Colorado (posting law) | 86% | 98 | |
| Illinois (posting law) | 71% | 35 | |
| Nebraska | 76% | 29 | |
| Louisiana | 49% | 43 | |
| Utah | 41% | 27 | |
| Wisconsin | 34% | 29 | |
| Kansas | 28% | 83 | |
| Oklahoma | 27% | 26 | |
| Oregon | 24% | 37 | |
| Arizona | 20% | 132 | |
| Tennessee | 19% | 70 | |
| Iowa | 17% | 42 | |
| Texas | 16% | 274 | |
| Missouri | 15% | 46 | |
| North Carolina | 11% | 55 | |
| Ohio | 11% | 36 | |
| Florida | 4% | 82 | |
| Georgia | 3% | 99 |
By role
| Role | Law states | Elsewhere |
|---|---|---|
| Project manager | 94% (187) | 25% (449) |
| Superintendent | 89% (119) | 22% (384) |
| Project engineer | 89% (161) | 21% (355) |
| Safety manager or director | 79% (29) | 15% (78) |
The pattern holds for every role. Project managers come closest to full disclosure where the law applies, and it doesn't carry over to the next state.
Four kinds of contractor
- 10 disclose only where required. 80% or more of postings in law states show pay, 20% or less elsewhere.
- 5 disclose everywhere. 75% or more in both kinds of state. This is why Nebraska and Louisiana sit well above Texas.
- 5 disclose more where required, but not consistently in either.
- 2 almost never disclose, including in law states.
We don't name contractors here. The point is the pattern: for most large contractors, whether a superintendent sees a number depends on the state, not the company.
What it means if you're hiring or looking
- Job seekers in Texas, Florida or Georgia: the same company very likely publishes a range for the same title in California, Colorado or Washington. It's a fair starting point for an offer conversation.
- Employers: a candidate can find your California range in a minute. Leaving it off your Texas posting hides it from the people least likely to apply, not from anyone determined to find it.
How we counted
- Every active job on SiteLeadJobs on November 3, 2026: 2,228 postings from 47 employers, nearly all collected from the employers' own career sites.
- Salaried roles only: superintendent, project manager, project engineer, and safety manager or director (2,063 postings). Foremen are left out because our extraction misses some hourly rates.
- "Shows pay" means the posting states a figure or range for the job. A posting in a no-law state that gives a range only for, say, California applicants counts as showing pay, so the 22% is if anything high.
- A state counts as a posting-law state for a job only if its rule was in force on the posting date: Colorado, California, Washington, New York, Hawaii, District of Columbia, Maryland, Illinois, Minnesota, New Jersey, Vermont, Massachusetts. Virginia, Maine, Connecticut started requiring ranges between July and October 2026 and are shown on their own. City rules (New York City, Jersey City, Cleveland) fall inside states already counted or were too small to matter.
- We checked the extraction against the original posting text for every posting by pattern search, and read a sample by hand. Under 1% of postings recorded without pay had a pay figure in the original, nearly all of them hourly.
- This is a snapshot of open jobs, not a trend, and not legal advice about any employer's obligations.
What earlier studies found
Economists have shown that posting laws raise disclosure and that firms don't carry it across state lines. None of these looks at construction field leadership.
- Arnold, Quach and Taska (NBER working paper, 2025): Colorado's law roughly doubled the share of postings with pay, from about 35% to about 70%, comparing the same firm, occupation and county over time. Construction is about 2% of their data and is not broken out.
- Minneapolis Fed (2024): Employers posting in mandate states were not much more likely to disclose pay in other states. No construction cut.
- New York Fed (2025): About a quarter of postings covered by a law in CO, CA, WA and NYC still left pay out. Broken out by firm size, not industry.
- Indeed Hiring Lab (2024): 57.8% of US postings showed pay, with New York, Washington and Colorado near the top and the South lower. No construction or same-employer comparison.